Skip to main content

A bourbon Old Fashioned is three ingredients and an orange peel: bourbon and bitters with a little sugar, plus the water the ice adds as you stir. With that few moving parts there is nowhere for a bad choice to hide, which is why it is worth getting each one right. If you’re mixing one at home in Charlotte tonight, everything you need fits on one shelf, and the bourbon we’d pour is made just up I-77. Here is the classic recipe, what the bartenders’ references say about the bourbon to use, and a few habits that make the difference between a good one and a great one.

The Recipe

This is the Bourbon Old Fashioned as Difford’s Guide makes it:

  • 2 oz bourbon
  • 1/4 oz demerara or brown sugar syrup (2 parts sugar to 1 part water)
  • 3 dashes Angostura bitters
  • Orange peel

Stir everything but the peel with ice in a mixing glass. Strain into a rocks glass over fresh ice, ideally one large cube. Squeeze the orange peel over the drink so the oils land on the surface, then drop it in.

The Sugar Cube Method

The International Bartenders Association keeps the sugar cube build on the books. Put a sugar cube in the glass, soak it with Angostura bitters, add a few dashes of plain water and muddle until the sugar dissolves. Fill the glass with ice, add the whiskey and stir gently. Garnish with orange and a cocktail cherry. It is a nice ritual, though Difford’s Guide comes down on the side of syrup, saying it “makes a smoother, better drink.”

Picking the Best Bourbon for an Old Fashioned

Because the bourbon is nearly the whole drink, it decides how the drink tastes. Proof and style are the two things to weigh. The bartenders’ references have opinions on both, and you can test both at home with a couple of bottles.

Proof. The bartenders Punch asked about this drink tend to reach for higher-proof bourbon. One recommends at least 90 proof, so the drink can stand up to dilution without being too hot. The ice is going to melt, so you want a whiskey that still has something to say after it does.

Style. Difford’s Guide puts it simply: bourbon makes a mellow, slightly sweeter drink, while rye adds more spice and kick. Difford’s own house recipe splits the difference and uses both.

Our own bar makes its Old Fashioned with either of the two bourbons below, and both work just as well at home. Paragon Bottled-in-Bond Wheated Bourbon is 100 proof, well past that 90 proof line. Its mash is 70% corn, 16% wheat and 14% malted barley, and it ages a minimum of 4 years. Southern Star Bourbon is 45% ABV, from a mash of 60% corn, 36% rye and 4% malted barley. It pours a rich amber with caramel and vanilla on the nose, then a subtle rye spice on the palate before a long, leathery finish. Mix one of each at home and see which you like better in the glass.

Small Habits That Make a Better Old Fashioned

Stir, do not shake. Difford’s Guide calls the stirring “essential to attaining the correct dilution.” The water from the ice is part of the recipe.

Use a big piece of ice. Difford’s Guide recommends a single large chunk of ice in the glass for the best look and dilution.

Do not skip the orange. In the words of Difford’s Guide, an Old Fashioned is “not complete without an orange zest twist.” The oils on top are the first thing you smell.

Where the Name Came From

In 1806 a newspaper in Hudson, New York called The Balance and Columbian Repository defined a cocktail as “a stimulating liquor, composed of spirits of any kind, sugar, water, and bitters.” That is an Old Fashioned, almost word for word. By the 1870s, bartenders were dressing up their whiskey cocktails with dashes of absinthe and curaçao, among other liqueurs. According to Difford’s Guide, drinkers who wanted the plain version started asking for an “Old-Fashioned Whiskey Cocktail,” and that is where the name comes from.

Taste the Bourbon at the Source, Up I-77 From Charlotte

You can make a very good Old Fashioned at home, and tasting the bourbon on its own tells you a lot about why it works, which is a good excuse for an afternoon drive up from Charlotte. Statesville was once called the Liquor Capital of the World, and our 20-acre campus has 65,000 barrels aging on site. The Old Fashioned is the go-to drink at our bar, a classic worth pouring. Guests 21 and older with a valid ID can stop by our tasting room and order one at the flame oak bar, or start with a flight. For the behind-the-scenes look first, book a Behind the Scenes Tour, which runs about 60 minutes at $15.00 per person and wraps up with a tasting at the bar. We keep directions to our distillery at 211 Jennings Road on the site.

Not making the trip this year? Find a bottle near you on our where to buy page and start with the recipe above. However you take yours, please drink responsibly, since an Old Fashioned is almost all bourbon and the ride home should always be a sober one.

Bourbon Old Fashioned FAQ

What do you need for a bourbon Old Fashioned?

Bourbon and Angostura bitters, plus a rich sugar syrup or a sugar cube. Finish it with ice and an orange peel.

Should an Old Fashioned be stirred or shaken?

Stirred. Difford’s Guide calls stirring essential to getting the dilution right.

What proof bourbon is best for an Old Fashioned?

Bartenders quoted by Punch favor higher proof, with one recommending at least 90 proof so the drink stands up to dilution. Paragon Bottled-in-Bond Wheated Bourbon is 100 proof.

Is an Old Fashioned made with bourbon or rye?

Either. The International Bartenders Association lists bourbon or rye whiskey. Bourbon makes a mellower, slightly sweeter drink.

Is the distillery an easy day trip from Charlotte?

Yes. It’s roughly 45 minutes, about 42 miles north on I-77 to Statesville. The bar doesn’t take reservations, so you can walk in for a flight, and tours are booked ahead online.

Pour one tonight. Then come taste where the bourbon comes from. Plan a visit to our tasting room in Statesville.