The first cool night of the year in Charlotte has a way of pushing the gin to the back of the cabinet. If you asked us what to pour instead, these are the four fall bourbon cocktails we’d point you to, and none of them asks for more than a regular grocery run. Each comes from a trusted source (America’s Test Kitchen, Difford’s Guide), two of them lightly adapted, and every one is made with Southern Distilling Company spirits from Statesville, NC, about 45 minutes up I-77. Two are easy enough for a weeknight and two reward a little effort on a Saturday, and after them comes the one our own bar is pouring this winter. None of them needs a pumpkin, and all of them taste better with a sweater on.
Bourbon Cider by the Pitcher
If you only make one bourbon cider cocktail this fall, make it this one. It comes from America’s Test Kitchen, and it is built for a crowd, with a pitcher on the counter, a bucket of ice and nobody stuck playing bartender all night. The ratio is 3 parts cider to 1 part bourbon, so it scales down easily for two, and the lemon keeps it from tasting like a juice box with ambition.
Makes 10 to 12 drinks
- 36 ounces (4 1/2 cups) apple cider
- 12 ounces (1 1/2 cups) Southern Star Bourbon
- 4 ounces (1/2 cup) fresh lemon juice
- Apple slices, for garnish
- Optional sugared rim: 2 ounces (1/4 cup) lemon juice and a plate of turbinado sugar
Stir the cider and bourbon together with the lemon juice in a large pitcher. For the rim, dip each glass in lemon juice, then in the sugar. Pour into old-fashioned glasses over an ice sphere or one large cube, and add an apple slice.
The Two-Whiskey Manhattan
A Manhattan is the drink for the night the jackets come out. Difford’s Guide makes its sweet Manhattan with mostly bourbon and a splash of rye, which happens to be exactly what we keep on our own shelves. Where Difford’s calls for a 100-proof straight rye, we pour Southern Star Double Rye Whiskey.
- 1 1/2 oz Southern Star Bourbon
- 1/2 oz Southern Star Double Rye Whiskey
- 1 oz sweet (rosso) vermouth
- 1 dash Angostura bitters
- Orange peel and a cocktail cherry
Stir everything with ice and strain into a chilled coupe. Squeeze the orange peel over the top, toss the peel, and drop in the cherry. In the glass, most of the work falls to Southern Star Bourbon, made from a mash of 60% corn, 36% rye and 4% malted barley and bottled at 45% ABV. It has caramel and vanilla on the nose and a subtle rye spice on the palate. Southern Star Double Rye Whiskey is a honey gold, full-bodied rye at 44% ABV, with fresh dill and green peppercorn on the nose and cinnamon and orchard fruit on the palate.
The Gold Rush With Paragon
The Gold Rush is a modern classic that started at Milk & Honey in New York in 2001. Difford’s Guide sums it up as a whiskey sour made with honey syrup in place of sugar, and honey with bourbon in the fall is about as seasonal as it gets. We make ours with Paragon Bottled-in-Bond Wheated Bourbon, which is 100 proof, made from a mash of 70% corn, 16% wheat and 14% malted barley, and aged a minimum of 4 years.
- 2 oz Paragon Bottled-in-Bond Wheated Bourbon
- 3/4 oz fresh lemon juice
- 3/4 oz honey syrup (3 parts honey to 1 part water, by weight)
- Lemon peel and a lemon wedge
Shake with ice, then fine strain into a chilled rocks glass over fresh ice. Squeeze the lemon peel over the drink and discard it, then garnish with the wedge.
A Mocha Martini With Double Shot Bourbon Cream Liqueur
The last of the four is the dessert course. Difford’s Guide’s Mocha Martini pairs bourbon and espresso with a cream liqueur, and we make ours with Double Shot Bourbon Cream Liqueur, which brings cream and a hint of espresso roast, with bourbon warmth underneath. Most of the coffee comes from the shot of espresso.
- 1 1/2 oz Southern Star Bourbon
- 1 oz espresso
- 1/2 oz Double Shot Bourbon Cream Liqueur
- 1/2 oz dark crème de cacao
- 6 drops chocolate bitters
- 1/2 oz whipping cream, to float
- Cocoa powder
Shake the bourbon, espresso, Double Shot Bourbon Cream Liqueur, crème de cacao and bitters with ice. Fine strain into a chilled coupe. Float the cream in the center and dust with cocoa. Our version makes two changes to the Difford’s recipe. It calls for Irish cream liqueur where we use Double Shot Bourbon Cream Liqueur. Its method also names only the first four ingredients for the shaker, so we add the bitters there too.
From Our Bar: The Apple Butter Old Fashioned
Our tasting room doesn’t create a specific fall menu, but the bar features a cocktail that changes through the year, and this one is worth knowing. Try the Apple Butter Old Fashioned at home, which carries the apple and spice of fall into the colder months. The recipe calls for bourbon, and at home Southern Star Bourbon is a good one to reach for.
- 2 oz bourbon
- 1/4 oz apple cider
- 2 tablespoons apple butter
- 2 dashes Angostura, chocolate or black walnut bitters
- 1 to 1 1/2 oz club soda
- 1/4 oz lemon juice (optional)
- A cinnamon stick or an apple slice
Shake everything except the club soda with ice, then strain it over fresh ice. Top with the club soda and garnish with the cinnamon stick or apple slice.
Where to Find These Bottles
If the home bar needs stocking, our tasting room in Statesville sells bottles of our core spirits, along with single barrels. Closer to home, our spirits are widely available in NC ABC stores. The where to buy list can point you to a shelf that carries them.
Fall Activities Near Charlotte, NC: Taste Them at the Source
Once you’ve made a few of these at home, the whiskey deserves a taste on its own, poured where it was made. Our distillery near Charlotte makes an easy fall Saturday, with a drive up I-77 and a flight waiting at the end of it. The award-winning tasting room pours flights and cocktails built on our own spirits across a flame oak bar, and you’ll want a valid ID showing you’re 21 or older if you plan to taste. Fall 2026 hours start at 10am Monday through Saturday, with closing at 6pm Monday to Thursday and 9pm on Friday and Saturday, and Sunday runs noon to 5pm.
If you’d like the whole story before the first sip, book a Behind the Scenes Tour. The tour takes about 60 minutes at $15.00 per person, leaves at the top of the hour every day, and finishes with a tasting at the bar. Tour times shift with staffing, so the booking page is the place to check what is open on the day you want.
Fall Bourbon Cocktails FAQ
What is the easiest fall bourbon cocktail to make for a crowd?
The bourbon cider pitcher. It is three ingredients plus ice, and you mix it once for 10 to 12 drinks.
What is a good bourbon cider cocktail ratio?
The America’s Test Kitchen recipe above uses 3 parts apple cider to 1 part bourbon, with a little fresh lemon juice.
Can I use rye instead of bourbon in these?
The Manhattan is the natural place for it. The International Bartenders Association’s Manhattan uses rye alone, and our version already includes Southern Star Double Rye Whiskey. The other three recipes are written for bourbon.
Does the Southern Distilling Company tasting room have a fall cocktail?
There is no fall menu, but the bar features a cocktail that changes through the year. One to try at home is the Apple Butter Old Fashioned, and the recipe is above.
Is the tasting room a good fall outing from Charlotte, and what should I book?
It’s about 42 miles from the city to our door at 211 Jennings Road in Statesville, roughly 45 minutes via I-77. The tasting room bar doesn’t take reservations, so the only things to book ahead are a Behind the Scenes Tour or a Cask to Cork bottling, both on the tours page.
Pick a recipe, pick a cool night, and pour one. Then come see where it all starts. When a free Saturday opens up, point the car up I-77 and visit our tasting room, where we will pour you the good stuff. At home or at our bar, please drink responsibly and plan a sober ride home.



